Affects Version/s: Release 1.2
Fix Version/s: Release 1.8
Patch:Code and Test
Behavior with Clojure 1.6.0:
Behavior with latest Clojure master as of Jun 27 2014 (same as Clojure 1.6.0) plus patch clj-700-7.diff. In all cases it matches the expected results shown in comments above:
Analysis by Alexander Redington: This is caused by expectations in clojure.lang.RT regarding the type of collections for some methods, e.g. contains() and getFrom(). Checking for contains looks to see if the instance passed in is Associative (a subinterface of PersistentCollection), or IPersistentSet.
This patch refactors several of the Clojure interfaces so that logic abstract from the issue of immutability is pulled out to a general interface (e.g. ISet, IAssociative), but preserves the contract specified (e.g. Associatives only return Associatives when calling assoc()).
With more general interfaces in place the contains() and getFrom() methods were then altered to conditionally use the general interfaces which are agnostic of persistence vs. transience. Includes tests in transients.clj to verify the changes fix this problem.
Questions on this approach from Stuart Halloway to Rich Hickey:
1. this represents working back from the defect to rethinking abstractions (good!). Does it go far enough?
2. what are good names for the interfaces introduced here?
Alex Miller: Should also keep an eye on CLJ-787 as it may have some collisions with this one.
One 'trailing whitespace' warning is perfectly normal when applying this patch to latest Clojure master as of Sep 1 2014, as shown below. This is simply because of carriage returns at the end of lines in file Associative.java. I know of no way to avoid such a warning without removing CRs from all Clojure source files (e.g. CLJ-1026):